The standard seal for a new toilet is a wax ring. However, a good seal can be achieved without wax.

In fact, because some materials perform better than wax, some plumbers think a waxless seal is the best seal. However, which wax-free toilet seal offers the most messes-free performance?

If you build a toilet yourself, a toilet wax ring is a popular option because it is straightforward. There are some significant drawbacks, though.

Wax rings are not heat-resistant, only available in a few sizes, and cannot be recycled. Given how quickly they wear out, it is unlikely that a conventional wax seal will come with a 10-year warranty.

Because they are simpler to use, heat-resistant, and clean, waxless seals are more widely used. A rubber seal, sometimes known as a Sani seal, is made of sturdy materials.

Additionally, there are seal choices that combine wax and rubber. These provide a better initial seal than wax alone, but not being fully waxless.
Rubber seal rings

Rubber Seal Rings

For the toilet bowl, rubber rings are provided with a reusable gasket. They are fastened to the toilet’s base.
The flange next moves into the drain pipe. Because it is the toilet flange that forms the watertight seal, it is crucial.
Your heated floors won’t flood as a result.
The O-ring is meanwhile used to protect the floor flange. The toilet is sealed against air and liquid leaks by this leak-proof ring.
Along with your toilet drain, it is in charge of keeping sewer gases out of your bathroom.

Every time you need to use your drain pipe, you can reset a rubber seal as opposed to a wax seal. This means that you avoid the mess and inconvenience of having to replace an entire seal.

As a result, it could be less expensive than a wax-based free seal.

You should select an Fluidmaster , Korky, or Danco option from Amazon if you plan to replace the seal as part of a home repair project. Regardless of the common flange heights, these typically don’t require an adaptor to attach to your drain.

The Fluidmaster Better Than Wax option or the Korky Wax-Free Seal option are our top picks for the best rubber seal.

Foam Seal Rings


Another reusable option for usage at the floor level is foam seal rings. They combine sponge, foam, and other strong materials instead of using rubber or wax.

The materials may adapt to the specifications of the toilets while still preventing leaks because they retain their shape. Another benefit is that you can reinstall one ring numerous times if you make a mistake because the materials are reusable.

A foam gasket might be especially appealing if you have a shaky toilet. These materials are more effective in preventing leaks on shaky models than rubber.

The movement causes the material to compress and expand. Make sure your toilet’s brass bolts are snug enough by checking them as well.
If necessary, a spacer can also be used as an adaptor. This will take care of most leak issues.

SEAL SANI The foam seal known as the Sani seal is constructed of rubber, sponge, PVC, and ABS plastic. It holds the gasket still while maintaining the upright position of your toilet’s bolts.

Additionally, it can fit any typical toilet flange.

This model can be stacked even if your flange is deep. Because of this, it is our top recommendation for people searching for a sealant that combines foam and rubber.

It should be noted, nevertheless, that reviewers have claimed that if the seal is destroyed, it is no longer functional. Water will flow inside if there is even the slightest damage.

For pure rubber seals, that is typically not a problem.
LAST THOUGHTS The majority of toilets come pre-installed with a wax seal. Waxless seals, however, have a lot of benefits.
They are less likely to leak, reusable, and simple to install.
Rubber and foam are the two most widely used types of waxless seal. Both of these choices offer benefits and drawbacks.
For individuals with irregular toilets, rubber seals work best. However, a foam seal can greatly improve overall stability for people whose toilets are more unsteady.





Enter your email address below to

subscribe to my newsletter